H. C. Mookherjee

  1. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38-AIf honourable members will kindly take their seats, I shall be able to say something. We have adopted a certain procedure. The amendments have to be move…
  2. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38-AIn that case you cannot speak.
  3. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38-AIn that case, you must wait till Shri Ram Sahai moves his amendment also No. 88, list IV.
  4. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38-ABut he has said he will be taking part in the general discussion only. Now, Shri Ram Sahai.
  5. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38-AThere is another amendment which I had overlooked. It is No. 1005, standing in the name of Shri Ranbir Singh Chaudhari.
  6. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38-AAll right. Professor Saksena.
  7. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38-AThe Honourable Member must address the Chair. This is not a public platform.
  8. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38-AFollowing my usual practice I must give an opportunity to people who hold different views from the majority view and I am therefore calling upon Mr. Lari…
  9. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38-AI shall now put the amendments one by one to the vote. The amendment of Pandit Thakur Dass Bhargava. That is No. 72 in List II.
  10. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38-AYou moved your amendment as an amendment to No. 1002 which was not moved.
  11. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38-AAll right. I am willing to put your amendment to the vote. Now, the amendment of Seth Govind Das, i.e., 73 in List No. II, is now put to the vote. The…
  12. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38-ANow amendment No. 72 in List II by Pandit Thakur Dass Bhargava is put to the vote. The question is: “That in amendment No. 1002 of the List of…
  13. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38-AArticle 38-A will consist of the amendment of Pandit Thakur Dass Bhargava. The question before the House is: “That article 38-A in the form just…
  14. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 39Shall we now go on to the next item in the agenda? No. 1003 has been covered by one of the previous amendments. No. 1004 has also been disposed of. Then…
  15. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 39There is another amendment in the name of Shri Ram Sahai, which is identical in words. I shall put this to vote.
  16. Mr. Vice President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 39I am now putting the amendments one by one. The question is: “That in article 39, after the words ‘from spoliation’ the word ‘disfigurement’ be inserted.”
  17. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 39There is the amendment of Prof. Shibban Lal Saksena.
  18. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 39There is no second part so far as I am aware. It only refers to deletion of certain words. The first part is the same.
  19. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 39I am afraid it is too late now. The question is: “That in article 39, after the words ‘from spoliation’, the word ‘disfigurement’ be inserted, and all…
  20. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 39The question is: “That in article 39, for the words ‘It shall be the obligation of the State to’, the words. ‘The State shall’ be substituted.”