H. C. Mookherjee

  1. Mr. Vice-President:GOVERNMENT OF INDIA ACT, 1935 (AMENDMENT BILL)The question is: “That leave be granted to introduce a Bill to amend the Government of India Act, 1935.”
  2. Mr. Vice-President:GOVERNMENT OF INDIA ACT, 1935 (AMENDMENT BILL)On what ground?
  3. Mr. Vice-President:GOVERNMENT OF INDIA ACT, 1935 (AMENDMENT BILL)I shall put the matter to vote. The question is: “That leave be granted to introduce a Bill to amend the Government of India Act, 1935.”
  4. Mr. Vice-President:GOVERNMENT OF INDIA ACT, 1935 (AMENDMENT BILL)The Bill has been introduced. Now may I ask Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel to give the House some idea of the time when he proposes to move for taking the Bill…
  5. Mr. Vice-President:GOVERNMENT OF INDIA ACT, 1935 (AMENDMENT BILL)Thank you. The House will now resume discussion of article 38 of the Draft Constitution. I now call upon Shri L. N. Sahu to speak.
  6. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38 (contd.)I have already called upon Mr. L.N. Sahu to speak.
  7. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38 (contd.)Mr. Tyagi is a great stickler for rights.
  8. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38 (contd.)That puts the matter in a new light.
  9. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38 (contd.)There are three amendments. One is by Mr. Mahavir Tyagi. That is No. 71 in List II. If I read the situation a right, that has been practically withdrawn.…
  10. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38 (contd.)I want to know whether you want that your amendment should be put separately to the vote.
  11. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38 (contd.)I understand the situation. I shall now put to the vote the amendment of Mr. Mahavir Tyagi as modified by Professor Shibban Lal Saksena and further…
  12. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38 (contd.)I take your permission on behalf of Dr. Ambedkar.
  13. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38 (contd.)This particular amendment as amended is now put to the vote.
  14. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38 (contd.)Then, there is another amendment which is No. 81 in List III moved by Sardar Bhopinder Singh Man to insert the word ‘tobacco’ between the words ‘drinks’…
  15. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38 (contd.)I now put to the vote article 38, as amended.
  16. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38 (contd.)We now come to new article 38-A—amendment No. 1002 standing in the names of Pandit Thakur Dass Bhargava and Seth Govind Das.
  17. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38-AThe honourable Member is perfectly entitled to speak in any language he likes but I would request him to speak in English though he is not bound to speak…
  18. Mr. Vice President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38-AYes, I am asking you to stop.
  19. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38-AYou have already had 25 minutes.
  20. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—contd.Article 38-AI am afraid that if I give you that permission, other speakers will not have sufficient time to speak. You asked for ten minutes and I have given you…