V. T. Krishnamachari
- Mr. Vice-President :REPORT OF THE UNION CONSTITUTION COMMITTEECLAUSE 18I propose to place before the House first the amendments regarding the removal clause. The first amendment is Sir Alladi Krishnaswami Ayyar’s which…
- Mr. Vice-President :REPORT OF THE UNION CONSTITUTION COMMITTEECLAUSE 18There is a further amendment by Mr. Ananthasayanam Ayyangar 21(b). I take it that that amendment is not pressed. I now put to the House Mr.…
- Mr. Vice-President :REPORT OF THE UNION CONSTITUTION COMMITTEECLAUSE 18I now put Mr. Ananthasayanam Ayyangar’s amendment 21-1(c) which is as follows: “A judge shall cease to hold office on his being adjudged an insolvent.”
- Mr. Vice-President:REPORT OF THE UNION CONSTITUTION COMMITTEECLAUSE 18I now place before this House Mr. Ananthasayanam Ayyangar’s amendment 19(a) which reads as follows: “Every Judge shall be a citizen of the Union of India.”
- Mr. Vice-President :REPORT OF THE UNION CONSTITUTION COMMITTEECLAUSE 18Amendment No. 19(a) is sought to be withdrawn. Does the House permit the withdrawal?
- Mr. Vice-President:REPORT OF THE UNION CONSTITUTION COMMITTEECLAUSE 18I now place before the House Mr. Santhanam’s amendment 8(c) in Supplementary List III: “(c) the salaries of the Chief Justice and other judges of the…
- Mr. Vice-President :REPORT OF THE UNION CONSTITUTION COMMITTEECLAUSE 18I now place before the House amendment No. 17 in List II: “That in para. 9 of the Appendix state: ‘(a) that the appellate jurisdiction of the Privy…
- Mr. Vice-President :REPORT OF THE UNION CONSTITUTION COMMITTEECLAUSE 18All right, the amendment will stand over. Now, Mr. Santhanam’s amendment No. 8(b).
- Mr. Vice-President :REPORT OF THE UNION CONSTITUTION COMMITTEECLAUSE 18Does the House permit the amendment to be withdrawn?
- Mr. Vice-President :REPORT OF THE UNION CONSTITUTION COMMITTEECLAUSE 18I now put the clause, as amended, to vote.
- Mr. Vice-President :REPORT OF THE UNION CONSTITUTION COMMITTEECLAUSE 18There are no amendments. I think all the proposals are the same. They conform to the paragraph in the memorandum, and there is no substantial difference.…
- Mr. Vice-President :REPORT OF THE UNION CONSTITUTION COMMITTEECLAUSE 18Does any member wish to speak on this proposed Clause 18A?
- Mr. Vice-President :REPORT OF THE UNION CONSTITUTION COMMITTEECLAUSE 18I understand Sir N. Gopalaswami Ayyangar’s assurance to mean that provision will be made for this in whatever parts of the Constitution such provision…
- Mr. Vice-President :REPORT OF THE UNION CONSTITUTION COMMITTEECLAUSE 19Now, we go to Clause 19.
- Mr. Vice-President :REPORT OF THE UNION CONSTITUTION COMMITTEECLAUSE 19There is only one amendment to Clause 19 by Shri Mohanlal Saksena (item No. 18 of Supplementary List No. 1).
- Mr. Vice-President :REPORT OF THE UNION CONSTITUTION COMMITTEECLAUSE 19Does any member wish to speak on the original Clause 19? The question is: “That Clause 19 be adopted.”
- Mr. Vice-President :REPORT OF THE UNION CONSTITUTION COMMITTEECLAUSE 21There is an amendment in the name of Mr. H. V. Pataskar.
- Mr. Vice-President :REPORT OF THE UNION CONSTITUTION COMMITTEECLAUSE 21I do not think Mr. Saksena meant his amendment in that sense; he probably meant it in a completely different sense.
- Mr. Vice-President :REPORT OF THE UNION CONSTITUTION COMMITTEECLAUSE 21The question is: “That in Clause 21, the following words be deleted: ‘on the advice of his ministers’.”