Skip to the text- Mr. K. M. Munshi (Bombay: General) :CLAUSE 1—DEFINITIONSI have given notice of certain verbal amendments to this clause. I could do this only this morning, and if you will be pleased to give me leave...…
- Mr. K. M. Munshi :CLAUSE 1—DEFINITIONSI have submitted to the Office certain verbal amendments to clause 1, which I have already presented to you, and I beg leave under our rules to move…
- Mr. K. M. Munshi :CLAUSE 1—DEFINITIONSBefore Mr. Kamath moves his amendment, may I say that mine is a verbal amendment to clause 1(i). If that is permitted to be moved, it will remove any…
- Mr. K. M. Munshi:CLAUSE 1—DEFINITIONSI beg to move that in clause 1, sub-clause (i), insert the words “for the purpose of this Annexure” between the words “State”; and “includes”. The reason…
- Mr. K. M. Munshi :CLAUSE 1—DEFINITIONSI will accept that.
- Mr. K. M. Munshi :CLAUSE 1—DEFINITIONSI have no objection, Sir. “Union” must mean the Union of India wherever it is.
- Mr. K. M. Munshi :CLAUSE 1—DEFINITIONSI have an amendment to clause 1, sub-clause (iii), that is purely verbal. Sub-clause (iii) says: “ ‘The law of the Union’ includes any law made by the…
- Mr. K. M. Munshi :CLAUSE 1—DEFINITIONSIt was felt by many that if the word ‘as’ is put in, it would mean something as may be in force. Otherwise the word ‘as’ should be deleted.
- Mr. K.M. Munshi :CLAUSE 1—DEFINITIONSIn clause 18 (3) (b) the word “schools” has not been used to narrow down the scope of the clause but to discriminate them from other educational…
- Mr. K. M. Munshi :CLAUSE 1—DEFINITIONSSir, I oppose this amendment. The definition is so, worded that if it is accepted. it will make any discrimination even on the ground of place of birth…
- Mr. K. M. Munshi :CLAUSE 3—CITIZENSHIPThese words were originally in the Report which was placed before the Advisory Committee, but it seems due to some oversight they did not find a place in…
- Mr. K. M. Munshi :CLAUSE 3—CITIZENSHIPSir, on a point of personal explanation I was in error in stating that this clause was omitted by mistake. I looked into the Minutes and I find that it…
- Mr. K. M. Munshi :CLAUSE 3—CITIZENSHIPMay I point out that the wording is “subject to jurisdiction”—That is the doctrine of allegiance. Persons born of foreigners, consuls and diplomats, will…
- Mr. K. M. Munshi :CLAUSE 3—CITIZENSHIP“Subject to jurisdiction” has been defined by several authorities and it means persons born of persons who owe allegiance to the Union. If necessary, I…
- Mr. K. M. Munshi :CLAUSE 3—CITIZENSHIPAs has been suggested by Dr. Katju, every child born of Indian parents should have the citizenship of the Union. Now as a matter of fact, the clause as…
- Mr. K. M. Munshi :CLAUSE 3—CITIZENSHIPThat will be better; they can meet and have a discussion because this is a purely technical discussion.
- Mr. K. M. Munshi :CLAUSE 3—CITIZENSHIPThree Committees have discussed this question threadbare and you can now nominate any persons you like and they can discuss it with you.
- Mr. K. M. Munshi :CLAUSE 4—RIGHTS OF EQUALITYMr. President, Sir. I move: 1. “That in clause 4 (1) the words ‘not discriminate’ may be substituted in place of ‘make no discrimination’.” It is merely…