H. C. Mookherjee

  1. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 19Do you want me to put amendment No. 580 to the vote?
  2. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 19Amendments Nos. 574, 581, 582 (second part), 587, 588 and 589 are of similar import and are to be considered together. Amendment No. 581 is allowed to be…
  3. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 19Do you like to say anything?
  4. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 19You need not dilate on it.
  5. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 19It seems that there is an amendment to this amendment. As I understand that it is not going to be moved, the next one that can be moved is only 591…
  6. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 19How can I guarantee that? I must observe a time table. Whether you get a chance or not will depend upon the shape the debate takes. You are at liberty to…
  7. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 19We shall resume the discussion on Monday. A request has come to me from my Muslim brethren that as today is Friday we should now adjourn. I think we…

  1. Mr. Vice-President (Dr. H. C. Mookherjee):DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 19—(Contd.)We shall now resume discussion on article 19.
  2. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 19—(Contd.)Ordinarily I do not allow manuscripts to be read, but if a Member feels that he cannot otherwise do full justice to the subject on hand, I allow him to…
  3. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 19—(Contd.)Mr. Lokanath Misra is moving an amendment to article 19. I ask the indulgence of the House because Mr. Lokanath Misra represents a particular point of…
  4. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 19—(Contd.)Order, order.
  5. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 19—(Contd.)There are two amendments in my list, i.e., 592 and 593. They are of similar import and may be considered together. Of these two, amendment No. 593…
  6. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 19—(Contd.)Amendment Nos. 594 and 595 are identical. I can allow amendment No. 595 to be moved.
  7. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 19—(Contd.)Amendment No. 596, Dr. Ambedkar.
  8. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 19—(Contd.)There are a number of amendments to this amendment. The first is amendment No. 11 of list I, standing in the name of Pandit Thakur Dass Bhargava.
  9. DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 19—(Contd.)Amendment No. 13 standing in the name of Mr. Naziruddin Ahmad is disallowed. For the words “the State” he wants the words “any State” to be substituted.
  10. DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 19—(Contd.)Amendment No. 601, Prof. K. T. Shah.
  11. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 19—(Contd.)Professor Shah—I cannot allow you to indulge in these remarks—I mean referring to the fate of your amendments and casting reflections on particular groups.
  12. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 19—(Contd.)I did not say “improper”. But it is bound to affect the calmness of the House and I would implore you.
  13. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 19—(Contd.)Nos. 604, 605, 607 and 608 are similar. I allow 604 and 607 to be moved.