H. C. Mookherjee

  1. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—Contd.Article 12Amendment Nos. 408 and 409 are verbal ones and therefore I disallow them. Now for general discussion. Mr. Kamath.
  2. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—Contd.Article 12I can allow you discussion on the clause as a whole, but cannot allow you to speak about your own amendment.

  1. Mr. Vice-President (Dr. H. C. Mookherjee):DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 12—(Contd.)We shall try to meet the wishes of the House. We finished our discussion on Article 12 and Dr. Ambedkar gave his reply. I am sorry I cannot accommodate…
  2. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 12—(Contd.)The question is: “That in clause (1) of article 12, after the word ‘title’ the words ‘not being a military or academic distinction’ be inserted.”
  3. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 12—(Contd.)The question is: “That in clause (1) of article 12, after the words ‘be conferred’ the words ‘or recognised’ be inserted”.
  4. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 12—(Contd.)The question is: “That in clause (1) of article 12, after the word ‘State’ the words ‘and the State shall in no way recognize any title conferred by the…
  5. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 12—(Contd.)The question is: “That in clause (1) of article 12, after the word ‘conferred’ the words ‘or recognised’ be inserted.”
  6. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 12—(Contd.)The question is: “That for clause (2) of article 12, the following clause be substituted. ‘(2) No title conferred by any foreign State on any citizen of…
  7. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 12—(Contd.)The question is: “That article 12, as amended, stand part of the Constitution.”
  8. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 13We shall now take up article 13 for consideration.
  9. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 13Do I understand that amendment No. 441 will not be moved? I shall not allow any discussion but I shall put it to vote. Do I understand that the mover…
  10. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 13Amendments Nos. 415 and 418. They are the same. I will allow amendment No. 415 to be moved. It stands in the names of Pandit Lakshmi Kanta Maitra and…
  11. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 13Proceed, Mr. Chattopadhyay.
  12. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 13Then we come to amendment No. 416 standing in the name of Prof. K.T. Shah.
  13. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 13Amendment Nos. 417 and 418 are of similar import. I can allow No. 417 to be moved. This amendment stands in the name of Mr. Lari.
  14. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 13Then amendment No. 418 which stands in the name of Shri Mukut Behari Lal Bhargava.
  15. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 13Amendment Nos. 420, 421 and 424 are of similar import and I suggest that the House should consider them together. I suggest that amendment No. 421 be…
  16. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 13Amendment No. 420. Is it pressed?
  17. DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 13You need not come. I only want to know whether you intend to press this, in which case, I shall put it to the vote.
  18. Mr. Vice-President:DRAFT CONSTITUTION—(Contd.)Article 13You can speak in the course of the general discussion, provided, of course, you get a chance. You have given me the power to rule out; take your seat,…